Gooey on the Inside

A dessert shop offering a variety of gooey, soft-centered cookies and other sweet treats.

Gooey on the Inside is a Black-owned, woman-owned dessert shop in New York City specializing in decadent, soft-baked cookies with gooey centers. Founded by Kellie Pizarro, the shop elevates the classic cookie with bold flavors, nostalgic textures, and premium ingredients that melt in your mouth.

From their signature “S’mores” and “Cookies n Cream” to stuffed and gluten-free varieties, Gooey on the Inside has gained a devoted following for delivering indulgent treats that are made in small batches and packed with love. The shop also ships nationwide, allowing cookie lovers everywhere to enjoy this sweet NYC experience.

Key Features & Benefits:

Famous for soft-baked, gooey-centered cookies
Handmade in small batches using high-quality ingredients
Available for local delivery and nationwide shipping
Seasonal specials and gourmet flavors

Use Cases:

Gifting unique and indulgent desserts
Satisfying late-night sweet cravings
Celebrating birthdays or corporate events
Supporting a Black woman-owned NYC bakery

Honors & Accreditations:

Featured in The New York Times, Forbes, and Thrillist
Recognized as one of NYC’s top cookie spots
Praised for originality, quality, and customer service

Purchasing & Availability:

Order online for nationwide shipping, local delivery, or pickup. Custom gift boxes and bulk orders available.

Hours of Operation:

Monday – Sunday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM

Accepted Forms of Payment:

Credit Card, PayPal, Apple Pay, Google Pay

Testimonials:

“Soft, gooey, and bursting with flavor—these cookies are unreal!” — Cookie Addict
“One bite and I was hooked. Perfect texture, amazing flavors.” — Repeat Customer